|
During my time as a member, I've noted the many
letters to The
Wanderer seeking advice on motorhome electrics. This four-part
series will hopefully shed some light on the subject - and
I trust may also assist those many motorhome owners whose systems
are operating unsatisfactorily. The material is basically an
abridged version of the relevant chapters from my forthcoming
book on campervan, motorhome (and caravan) mechanical and electrical
systems that I hope to have in print in about nine months.It
is abundantly clear that a substantial proportion of campervan
and motorhome electrical systems do not work to their owner's
satisfaction. Attempts at rectification (larger alternator,
bigger batteries) are commonly less than successful.
To understand why it is first essential to appreciate that motorhome
electrical systems are functionally quite different from those
in cars. Campervan systems are different too, but to a lesser
degree.The difference is this. Cars and trucks require electrical
energy primarily whilst they are moving. Campervans/motorhomes
require electrical energy primarily whilst they are at rest.
Whilst the above might seem blindingly obvious, the fundamentally
different approach that is required in the respective electrical
systems is rarely understood by motorhome owners. Worse (and
as equipment suppliers in this field will confirm) - these different
requirements are rarely understood either by auto-electricians.
Campervans/motorhome owners do not require a deep understanding
of the technicalities of vehicle electrics, but rather an appreciation
that their vehicles' and car/trucks' electrical systems have
substantially different functions - and must be put together
accordingly.
We'll start by having a brief look at
the electrical systems of cars and trucks. These vehicles
have one main battery (or, as with larger trucks, two batteries
coupled together to function as one). The major role of this
battery is to start the engine. The battery also powers an
interior light, energises electric door locks, keeps the electric
clock running (and enables the alternator to start charging
when the engine first turns over), but negligible power is
required for these tasks.
Once the engine has started, every single electrical need (ignition,
fuel pump, lights, radio, air conditioner etc) is thenceforth
supplied by the alternator.
To start the engine, the starter battery supplies a very high
current, but as it only does so for a few seconds the energy
typically drawn is that required to power a sidelight globe for
less than an hour. The alternator replaces this energy in a few
minutes, but only to the level where the battery can reliably
restart the engine (70%-75% of full charge). The charge rate
is then drastically reduced, to a level that is so low it will
take ten to twelve hours for the battery to achieve 85% of full
charge this is done so that the battery will not be overcharged
in taxis, long distance transport vehicles etc where charging
may continue virtually non-stop.
This reduced charge rate is just acceptable for a campervan that
is driven several hours each day, but it is next to useless for
a motorhome where, (unless supplemented by other sources of energy)
the batteries must supply sufficient electrical energy to supply
all needs when the vehicle is stationary perhaps for several
days.The 'obvious' cures of (a) fitting a larger
alternator, and (b) fitting larger batteries, make less difference
than one might reasonably expect. Regardless of battery or alternator
capacity, a standard car/truck voltage regulator 'perceives'
your alternator/ battery as a starting system and charges it
accordingly, i.e. reasonably quickly to 70% - 75% charge. Unbelievably
slowly thereafter.
At first sight this might not seem too bad: after all, you might
reasonably say, 70% - 75% battery charge is close to three-quarters
full. But it IS that bad - a battery cannot
be safely discharged below 50 or so per cent, and if you do so
its life will be drastically shortened, typically to a score
or so of such cycles.
In practice then, usable battery capacity starts at 50% charge.
A 100 ampere/hour battery thus has a theoretical capacity of
50% - but only if l00% charged. Which it will never be. If the
battery is only 70%-75% charged (as is typical of most systems)
the usable capacity of our 100 ampere/hour battery is 20 - 25
ampere/hours.
It's actually worse than that because, like people, batteries
degenerate with age - losing at least 10% of total capacity each
year.
Realistically, using good newish batteries, in a well thought-out
motorhome system, a nominal 100 ampere/hour battery can be reliably
charged to a bit over 90% capacity, thus providing about 45 or
so ampere/hours.
In many instances, particularly where the owner has accurately
calculated the battery requirements, the batteries already installed
may well be adequate - they have only appeared to be undersized
because they were not being adequately charged.
In other instances, larger batteries may be required.
But whilst larger capacity batteries are capable of storing more
energy, that energy must first be produced - and as we have seen,
the standard charging system is fundamentally incapable of doing
so in a realistic length of engine-running time.
To charge your existing or larger batteries adequately you will
almost certainly need a larger output alternator than that fitted
as standard, but fitting a larger alternator is not in itself
enough.
However it is also necessary to replace the existing voltage
regulator, which is increasingly commonly housed within the alternator,
by a so-called 'smart regulator' or other system that enables
the alternator to charge the batteries at a faster rate. This
is the vital key to a successful electrical system, and will
be covered in detail later in this series of articles.
Once the fundamentals are understood, fixing the various
problems is relatively easy. Here's what must be done:
If physically feasible, an excellent approach is to install a
second, electrically separate, alternator, regulator and batteries
to supply the house needs, retaining the original system for
starting etc. This is generally possible with coach and truck
based motorhomes, but there is not usually sufficient space around
the engine in cars and campervans.
If you do use this approach, you still need to apply the general
principles outlined in this series of articles.If the existing
single alternator system is preferred, the essential requirements
are (1) and (2) below.
1. To install a system that parallels the starter and
house batteries (for charging) when the engine is running,
but separates them automatically the moment the engine stops.
2.To install a high output alternator and modified,
or 'smart' regulator that will allow the alternator to recharge
the batteries quickly and fully.
It may also be necessary
to install house batteries large enough to supply two/three
days needs - preferably so-called 'deep-cycle' batteries that
will withstand frequent discharging to 45%-50% of full capacity
(my second article discusses batteries in more detail and shows
how to estimate needs and assess required battery capacity).
Optionally, we may also add solar panels, battery chargers or
a generator to assist battery charging whilst stationary. This
approach, particularly the use of solar panels will be covered
in the third article in this series.Also optionally, it helps
to have a system that measures and displays the batteries' state
of charge. Note here though that this cannot be assessed from
battery voltage - unless the batteries have 'rested' for about
24 hours.
The existing starter battery can be retained, or upgraded
if there is doubt about its adequacy.
Starter batteries can be used to supply the house needs, but
will degrade quickly. Deep-cycle batteries are a better although
more expensive choice for prolonged life and long-term reliability.
Good deep cycle batteries cost about $1.70 per nominal ampere/hour.
A high output alternator is required - preferably 120 amp minimum
(with a suitable regulator it is safe to charge batteries up
to 25% of their nominal ampere/hour capacity). A high output
alternator will cost $150 - $300.
The alternator regulator must be modified or replaced by a so-called
'smart regulator' (about $400).Other car, truck, caravan or boat
components, such as switching solenoids, light globes, fans etc
are readily usable. These components are available in a wide
range of quality and prices, with the better quality items stocked
mainly by boat equipment vendors.
The first part of this series discussed the major differences between
campervan/motorhome and car/truck electrics. It outlined the more
common problems and briefly described their remedies.
This second part covers the 'house' system. It details the electrical
devices that can realistically be used and those that cannot. It
shows how to assess the energy required to run those devices, whether
your requirements are realistic, and if so, how to scale your system
accordingly.If you stay exclusively at powered sites you can run
virtually anything you'd use at home - including full air conditioning.
You can also do this if you have a big motor/generator - but only
very large coach-based motorhomes have the requisite carrying capacity
for the 10/20 kilowatt devices required.But if, like my wife (Maarit)
and I, camping heaven is the bush or a quiet river bank, rather
than a caravan park with generators thumping away every evening,
you'll need to reduce electricity usage to the minimum.Away from
the power mains and/ or large/generator sets it is not practicable
to use electricity for any device intended to produce substantial
heat (excepting only small microwave ovens). Air conditioning can
only realistically be run from 240 volt mains power or a large
generator.
The major limitation is that storage batteries are a convenient
but hugely inefficient way of holding energy. With present-day
and foreseeable technology, the batteries required to supply full
'home-like' usage would weigh between 5000 kg and 10,000 kg for
each day between charges. This is clearly not feasible, even for
the largest of coach-based rigs.
Unless tied to mains supplies, or carrying a 10 kW motor
generator, you'll need to limit electrical usage to lights, radios,
cassette/CD players, TVs, fans, blenders, microwave ovens (small),
and efficient (and preferably chest-type) refrigerators.
It is more efficient to use 12-volt devices rather than 240 volt
devices via an inverter - unless you buy one of the recent (and
seriously expensive) inverters that are close to 100% efficient.
Use gas for ovens, grills, toasters, space heaters, etc: there
is more energy in a nine kilo gas bottle than can be stored in
I 000 kg of the most efficient batteries yet made.
Chest-type refrigerators are very much more efficient than the
front-opening types. The 30 litre 12 volt Engel chest opening refrigerator
in our VW Kombi uses around 30 ampere/ hours per day. Our 70 litre
(eutectic) Australian-made Autofridge in our OKA is almost unbelievably
efficient - less than 20 ampere/hours a day in mid-summer.
The very popular gas/electric front-opening refrigerators are efficient
when running off gas, and are practicable to power from the vehicle's
alternator, but their current consumption (typically 12 or more
amps) is three/ four times that of the 12 volt top-opening devices
- far too high for running from battery supplies. And their energy
consumption is worsened by all the cold air falling out every time
the door is opened.
sHaving established what is realistic to use, and what
is not, the next step is to calculate one's daily electrical
consumption and assess whether what you'd like is electrically
realistic.
Using Table I as an example, make up your own Table and calculate
the average daily current consumption as follows:
1. Take the current drawn by each device and
enter it against each item in column. If there's more than one
of each item (as with lights) enter the total current drawn by
them all.
2. For each entry in column 1, write down (in column 2) the maximum
number of hours that each device will be in use each day.
3. Multiply each entry in column I by each entry in column 2.Enter
this in column 3.
4. Total the entries in column 3. This figure is the consumption
in amp/hours each day.
This table is for 12 volt systems. For 24 volt systems,
halve the current consumption. A refrigerator
cycles on and off continuously. The figure used above
is typical for a small (40 litre) well-ventilated chest-type
unit set to 4 degrees Centigrade, on a typical summer day.
This when figure may vary by 50% or more from model
to model .
Deep cycle batteries cannot be discharged continuously
- repeatedly below 45%-50% of full capacity without progressive
damage. Thus a nominally I 00 ampere/hour battery
has an effective capacity (new) of 40-45 ampere/hours if discharged
over a period of not less than 20 hours or so, i.e. it's good
for 5 amps.
The examples in Table I are typical for a campervan, caravan
or small/ medium sized motorhome (and are those of my OKA). If
your totals are more than 30% or so higher than shown, you may
need to rethink your requirements, or provide supplementary means
of charging (see below).
The next step is to calculate the battery capacity required to
store this energy. This depends on the intervals between recharging
(by whatever means) - and on supplementary sources of energy
such as solar panels.
As noted in the first part of this series, a battery
can only realistically be charged to 90% of full capacity (and
even that requires a optimal charging system) and even the so-called
deep cycle batteries cannot be discharged repeatedly below 45%
- 50% of full capacity without progressive damage.Thus a nominally
100 ampere/hour battery has an effective capacity (when new)
of 40-45 ampere/hours if discharged over a period of not less
than 20 hours or so, i.e. it’s good for 5 amp for about
20 hours, but less if discharged at a higher rate (typically
10amps for about 9 hours, 20 amps for about 4 hours etc. Taking
our daily consumption (from Table 1) of 60 ampere/hours, we thus
need battery capacity nominally (i.e. what the maker claims)
rated at 140 ampere/hours or so for every 24 hours between charging.
(it’s advisable to have a bit more)
| |
Typical Hours |
Day Total Consumed |
Consumption Per day |
Lights |
3 |
4 |
12 |
Radio |
1 |
1 |
1 |
Cassette player |
2 |
1 |
2 |
Portable TV |
2 |
2 |
4 |
Refrigerator |
3.5 |
8* |
28 |
Water pump |
4.0 |
0.25 |
1 |
Fan |
1 |
3 |
3 |
Microwave oven |
40 |
0.25 |
10 |
TOTAL AMP/HOURS PER DAY |
|
|
61.0 |
This will allow for battery aging - 150/160 ampere/ hours for
every 24 hours between charging adds a comfortable but not excessive
'ageing' margin.If you'd like to have 48 hours between charges,
you'll need about 300-320 ampere/hours/. For
72 hours, you'll need about 450-480 ampere/ hours.
You must now decide whether this is feasible - in terms
of, cost weight and space.
As a rough guide, good deep-cycle batteries cost about $175,
and weigh about 40-50 kg, per nominal 100 ampere/hours. Batteries
themselves are not physically large but they, unless of the totally
sealed variety, must be located in a well-ventilated area. Allow
about 0.02 cubic metres per nominal 100 amp/hours.
Starter batteries can be used for 'house' needs, but they are
less than enthused about being discharged to 50% at all,-and
will suffer virtually certain failure if you do so more than
a score or so times. Starter batteries are however a lot cheaper
and a bit lighter than deep-cycle batteries. They are worth considering
if you are doing a six-month trip and can afford to write off
their cost afterwards. But for long term continuous use deep-cycle
batteries are really the only choice.
The so-called suspended gel batteries are a viable alternative.
They are more costly than conventional lead
acid deep cycle batteries, but because they can be discharged
more deeply without damage, a 70 amp/hour gel battery adequately
replaces a 1 00 amp/ hour lead acid battery.They require no ventilation
and can be housed at any angle (including upside down!). Before
specifying however, check out your proposed system with the manufacturers,
as these batteries are deeply upset if charged at higher than
14.4 volts.
The need for battery capacity can be reduced by:
1. Reducing the demand.
2. Reducing periods between recharging.
3. Supplementary charging. Reducing the demand is obvious, but
if you intend to use only electric lighting and refrigeration,
your absolutely minimum daily consumption will still be 30 -
40 ampere/hours.
Reducing times between charging is also obvious (but not necessarily
convenient).
The remaining alternative is supplementary charging.
Here, solar panels are by far my preferred choice. (The two by
77 watt panels on my OKA provide virtually all of our required
daily energy requirement).
Here's a few solar panel facts.
Firstly, disregard solar panel makers' claims for wattage output
- the actually achieved maximum wattage of all solar panels,
of which I am aware, is about 80% of their manufacturers', quoted
figures. The discrepancy is due to an industry-standard method
of measurement that is so electrically romantic one wonders that
the promotional literature is not written in iambic pentameter.
Reality is about 80% of the advertised output. To convert to
amps - divide that figure by twelve (for 12 volt systems),
For most of Australia you can safely assume you'll average the
resultant amount for four to five hours a day in the summer;
and three to four hours a day in the winter. Continued overcast
conditions will reduce this by about half. In desert, central
and northern parts of Australia, daily output may be IO-
15% higher.My OKNs two 77 watt panels generate a bit
over 60 watts per panel about 10 amps - at full output. I thus
have up to 10 amps available for three to five hours each day,
i.e. 30 - 50 ampere hours, or about 35 - 60 ampere/ hours in
central and northern latitudes.
The above figures are for the panels mounted more or less flat
on the roof on my vehicle. Except perhaps for Tasmania, it's
not worth optimising solar angles. The gain is well under 10%
even in mid-winter - and you'll only achieve that if you remember
to move them several times a day.
Some users like to have the panels completely portable so that
the vehicle can be placed in the shade and the panels in the
full sun. This is fine in theory, but (a) it's not clever to
park under trees, (b) you'll get sick' and tired of positioning
the panels every time you stop - and they are also eminently
steal able. Better by far to have them permanently mounted and
permanently connected.
The nominal (claimed) wattage output of solar panels is 90 -
100 watts/ square metre, they weigh about 15 kg per 100 watts
and cost about $1000 per 100 watts. You'll also need a solar
regulator ($80 - $180).So - if, from Table I you've worked out
that you need 60 ampere/hours per day, than from the above data
you can see that, adding one 77 watt panel producing (in winter)
15-20 ampere/hours will reduce total energy to be stored by that
amount - i.e. to 40 ampere/ hours. Two panels will produce 30-40
ampere/hours, thus reducing required stored energy to only 20-30
ampere hours.
This of course results in huge savings in required battery capacity
- or much longer periods between charging.
Adding solar panels provides a further major benefit: batteries
last very much longer if kept close to fully charged. Solar panels
achieve just that. Alternative methods of supplementary charging
are to run the vehicle's engine and alternator whilst stationary,
or to use a motor/generator.
Both alternatives are noisy. The former is practicable given
a high-output alternator and smart regulator. A well set-up combination
will charge the batteries at 60 - 75 amps and, given such a regulator,
batteries can safely be charged at up to 25% of their nominal
amp/hour capacity.
The latter is theoretically practicable but as most small generators
have very limited 12volt output, it is necessary to use the 240
volt output via a high capacity battery charger.
A further and not overly-complex alternative (for the mechanically
Sept) is to make your own generator using a suitable (preferably
4-stroke engine) and a high output alternator and smart regulator.
An absolute must for any campervan/ motorhome electrical
system is to ensure that the 'house' batteries are automatically
isolated from the starter battery when the engine is not running,
i.e. reserving the starter battery for that purpose alone.
A
good and theoretically simple solution is to have two quite
separate systems: i.e. a second, engine-driven alternator and
regulator connected directly to the house batteries, retaining
the original vehicle electrical system as is. This is an excellent
and virtually foolproof approach, but installing such a system
is not a job for the inexperienced, nor is it mechanically
practicable unless there is ample room around the engine to
mount a second alternator.
A more common approach is to connect or isolate the starter battery
by changeover switches, switching diodes, or solenoids. Changeover
switches and diodes are rarely specified nowadays, but I've included
them as many older vehicles use these methods - and they can
be a cause of unsuspected woes.
Battery Changeover Switches
Still commonly used on boat systems, a battery changeover switch
enables both starter and house batteries to be connected to the
alternator for charging; either or both batteries to be paralleled
for winching or starting; and either or both batteries to be
used for supplying the house loads - although in practice it
is more than prudent to reserve the starter battery exclusively
for that purpose.
With this system the changeover switch must be manually operated
every time you stop and start the engine for any length of time
- and sooner or later you will forget to do it. Usually sooner.
There is a further and potentially major drawback.
An alternator totally relies on the connected battery to provide
its voltage reference. If the battery is disconnected, even momentarily,
the alternator goes into voltaic lunar orbit, burning out its
rectifying diodes and often the regulator as well.
Most battery changeover switches safeguard against this by connecting
the second battery before disconnecting the first, or momentarily
disabling the alternator's field winding (which cuts alternator
output). But a dirty or loose switch contact represents instant
death to the alternator (as can a dirty battery connection).
Diode IsolatorsDiode isolators allow the alternator to charge all batteries
in parallel, and automatically separates them when current is
required to be drawn.
This method is reasonably effective (but see below) with older
vehicles in which the voltage regulator is located externally
from the alternator, but it can cause havoc with modern vehicles
which have complex electronic management systems.
This latter problem can be overcome, but still leaves a further
major failing of diode isolation: that it delivers the greatest
charge to the flattest battery. However it's the starting battery
that needs charging priority - and it is not helpful for it to
have to compete for power with a battery supplying, say, a blender
and the TV!
This is the most common way of isolating the starter
battery. It is simple and relatively trouble-free.
A solenoid is a switch that closes when electric current flows
through an associated coil. A lead from the ignition system applies
power to the solenoid coil when the ignition is switched on thereby
actuating the solenoid, and causing its contacts to parallel
the starting battery and the house batteries across the charging
circuit. When the ignition is turned off the solenoid deactivates,
thus electrically separating the batteries. The system can also
be used with diesel-engine vehicles by wiring the solenoid across
any electrical device that is activated when the engine is running,
and is de-activated when the engine is turned off, e.g. an oil
pressure sensor.The above system works reasonably well, but has
a few less obvious problems.The biggest such problem is that
interconnected but unequally charged batteries have Marxist tendencies
they attempt to equalise their charges, i.e. the more charged
battery discharges into the lesser charged battery until charges
are equal.
This is not necessarily helpful. If the house battery is flat,
the starter battery will begin to charge the house battery (via
the now-closed solenoid contacts) the moment the engine is started.
If the engine were to stall at any time during the next two or
three minutes, both batteries may now be too discharged to restart
the engine.
To overcome this, we need to give the starter battery priority,
by preventing the solenoid from energising until the engine is
well and truly running, or preferably only energising when the
starter battery is at a voltage high enough to ensure restarting.
A partial solution is to energise the solenoid via the oil pressure
sensor here the engine must have started and be running above
a certain speed before the solenoid cuts in. But if the engine
stalls shortly after starting, a flat house battery could still
have drained the starting battery before either had a chance
of being charged by the alternator.
A safer way (and that used by the author) is to use a device
that continuously monitors starter battery voltage and energises
the solenoid only when that voltage exceeds (say) 13.2 volts.
If at any time, and for any reason, this battery drops below
13.2 volts, the full alternator/regulator output is directed
to this battery -thus ensuring that it is available for starting.
Apart from a manually operated changeover switch, none
of the above solutions, on their own,necessarily allow batteries
to be paralleled for winching. This can be done by incorporating
a dash-mounted switch (and associated pilot light) that energises
the solenoid directly thus paralleling the batteries whether
the engine is running or not. If you intend to do this, you'll
need to use a solenoid capable of handling at least 200 amps
- preferably more, or, as I've done in my OKA, using a second
heavy duty paralleled solenoid just for this purpose.
(A simpler way of course is to use jumper leads, but do be aware
that even the so-called 'heavy duty' jumper leads sold by most
suppliers are generally useless for starting a large (3 litre
plus) diesel when cold.) Cheap solenoids have brass contacts
- they are fine for a time, but eventually the contacts tarnish,
leading to burnt contact surfaces, and large voltage drops. Better-quality
solenoids have silver alloy or pure silver contacts. These are
less prone (but still not totally immune) to corrosion.
Follow solenoid fitting instructions carefully - some solenoids
must be fitted apparently upside down to enable gravity to
assist the closing action!
As emphasised in the first two parts of this
series, only in the rarest of circumstances will a battery ever
achieve 100% charge. To do so requires specialised charging equipment
and entails charging for very long periods of time.
In practice, most standard vehicle systems will, at best, bring
a battery to 70 - 75% of full charge, thus leaving a mere 20
- 25% of nominal battery capacity available for use. A realistic
target to work towards is 90% -95% of full charge (thus leaving
40 - 45% capacity available). To achieve this is not difficult
but it can only be done by using an adequate capacity alternator
and a regulator (or battery control system) that is made specifically
for the purpose. A fully charged battery has a potential of about
12.8 volts. This falls to about 12.2 volts when the battery is
about 50% discharged - and to about 11.8 volts when 70% discharged.
Today's alternator regulators and battery chargers are set to
limit charging voltage to somewhere between 14.2 and 14.4 volts
(earlier regulators were set at 13.8-13.9 volts) and the difference
between the charging voltage and the battery voltage determines
the charging rate, i.e. as battery voltage rises, charging rate
automatically falls. Charging batteries from a standard alternator
and regulator is cheap and simple but is not effective unless
the vehicle is driven for many hours. Typically, an alternator
and regulator will charge a starting battery at 30 - 50 amps
for a few minutes, but this rate quickly drops, typically to
four or five amps and falling. With the standard car system almost
invariably supplied with a motor home, a 100 ampere/hour battery
that is 50% discharged will require ten hours or more driving
time before it is even 80% to 85% charged. It is unlikely ever
to be charged beyond 85% unless the vehicle is driven 12 or more
hours each day.
As a result, vehicles that are not in more or
less constant use are likely to have batteries that are around
70% charged. This is no use for house batteries that must operate
from about 50% to 90% of full charge.
I cannot emphasise too strongly that house batteries in motorhome
electrical systems have little chance of being adequately charged
by a standard vehicle alternator and regulator. Installing a
larger capacity alternator will not help because the regulator
will maintain the previous charging regime.If a vehicle charging
system is to cope with house batteries, it must be modified accordingly.
The almost universal failure to understand this is the cause
of most recreational vehicle electrical problems.Such modification
may, or may not involve upgrading the alternator, but it will
involve installing a 'smart' regulator or battery management
system designed for the purpose.
The second part of this series showed how to
determine the amount of electrical energy you need to generate
each day - probably 50 - 80 ampere/hours for a modest system.We
need now to determine whether the standard alternator can cope
with this extra load, or whether (as is probable) we need to
specify and fit an alternator of higher capacity.
Standard car or truck alternators typically generate 50 - 60
amps for short periods and about 60% of that continuously, i.e.
about 30 amps.
Of that 30 amps, 20-25 amps will be required for the vehicle's
running needs. This leaves only 5 - 10 amps safely available
for house battery charging, without risking overloading the alternator.
A good rule is to fit an alternator rated at about a quarter
or third of the total amp/hour capacity of the batteries that
it will be charging. A 120 amp alternator is usually adequate.
Alternators with outputs greater than 120 amps will require larger
width pulleys and drive belts to take the extra load..High output
alternators are readily obtainable from auto electricians. They
are usually direct replacements for the original (which are worth
keeping as spares).A 120 amp alternator is quite safe to use
indefinitely at 60% output and for short periods at 80% capacity,
so with the vehicle's running needs as before we now have at
least 50 amps available for battery charging - more than enough
for all but the larger coach-based motor homes with all mod cons.
A different and alternative but more costly approach to the above
is to install a 'KKK' specified alternator. These are designed
to produce their rated output continuously (if anyone knows of
an Australian supplier I'd appreciate a call - but they are readily
obtainable in the USA).
We have now determined the energy requirement we need, the battery
capacity required, and whether we need to upgrade the alternator.
(But once again I reiterate that upgrading the alternator alone
will not result in substantially increased charging).
An alternator's output is controlled by varying the amount of
current through its field winding (a series of connected coils
surrounding the revolving stator inside the alternator).
The voltage regulator, which is located inside the alternator
or externally, controls the alternator field winding current
- and hence the alternator output voltage.
To operate satisfactorily with recreational vehicles, the regulator
must be modified or overridden in such a way that the alternator
is allowed to charge the batteries at a higher current for a
longer period of time.
If you have a good practical knowledge of electricity, manually
overriding the regulator is quite easy. All that is required
is to supply a controlled de voltage to the alternator, field
via switched resistors or a high current rheostat. For fast charging,
the manual control is set so that the voltage across the battery
is about 14.4. Once the batteries are around 80% charged, the
voltage is reduced to around 13.9 volts, or the manual control
switched off.
This approach has been used for decades by cruising yachties
but it does require a thorough understanding of the charging
process, and considerable self-discipline to monitor what's happening.
There is a very real risk of cooking the alternator or batteries
- or both (although the former can be safeguarded against by
arranging for the maximum manually set charging current to be
less than the alternator's safe continuous maximum output).Whilst
I recommend against it, if you are prepared to risk this technique,
a good practical guide to all this is included in 'The
12 Volt Doctor's Handbook' by Edgar J. Beyn (published by Weems & Plath,
ISBN; 1-878797-00X) obtainable from boat equipment suppliers. Commercial
devices that work in similar ways are available from marine suppliers;
generally similar versions incorporating overcharging limiting
are also commercially available.
In the author's opinion, a better but more costly solution is
to fit a so-called ‘smart regulator'. A smart regulator
charges batteries at a high but safe level until the batteries
are about 90% charged, and then cuts the rate to avoid overcharging.
These regulators reduce charging time to well under half.
Some, such as the Hella regulator in our OKA, use a cycling technique
alternating high and low charge rates. In our OKA the high rate
is up to 100 amps - a bit alarming when experienced for the first
time!
(A few motor home owners have told me of bad experiences with
Hella regulators. These problems seem to concern an earlier type
that had inadequate cooling for Australian conditions.)These
types of regulator are extensively used on cruising and 'round-the-world'
racing boats. They cost $300 upwards and are readily available
from boating suppliers.
The best known are made by the (US) Ample Technologies,
and Cruising Equipment Company, and the (British) Adverc BM,
TWC, and Hella companies.The devices cost from $350
upwards. They are reasonably simple to install, but it's best
to have someone experienced in this area to do it for you unless
you are sure you know what you are doing. Boat electricians (who
typically have the know-how) are often strangely reluctant to
work on anything except boats, but telephoning around will usually
locate a willing soul.
It is extremely useful to know the batteries'
state of charge: apart from the convenience of knowing how many
hours lighting etc are left, batteries are damaged by over-discharging
(i.e. below 50%) and some electrical equipment (particularly
motors) may be damaged if run at low voltage. Unfortunately battery
voltage provides only a very rough indication of the state of
charge; any more than very minor rates of charge and discharge
initially and primarily affect the surface layer of the battery
plates. The voltage across a fully charged battery is about 12.8
volts, but so, for a minute or two, is that of an almost flat
battery that has been briefly charged at a high charge rate.
A 50% discharged battery will have a rested voltage of about
12.2 volts (as may a far more charged battery if measured directly
after applying a heavy load).
It takes time for a charge or discharge to 'soak through'. Hence,
unless a battery has had a chance to rest for 12-24 hours, a
voltage measurement reflects only the surface conditions.
An accurate expanded scale (i.e. reading from 11 - 15
volts) enables one to monitor charging voltage but unless it's
of high quality it's next to useless remember that the range
from fully charged to 50% charged is only 6%.
Apart from the very messy and tedious process of taking hydrometer
readings of the battery acid, the only accurate way of monitoring
battery charge is via specialised, and currently expensive, battery
charge monitors.
These devices measure both the charge current going into the
batteries, and the current drawn out of the batteries, and (allowing
also for charging inefficiencies) indicate the present battery
charge. There's so much to this subject that, editor permitting
(which, having been one myself, seems improbable in the extreme),
this series of articles could continue for at least 12 more issues.So
rather than pushing my luck I've finished by covering various
matters, including the use and abuse of 240 volt inverters, and
mains power; and have included a few hopefully useful tips on
wiring. I've also included a selection of questions asked by
members.
In the latter regard, 1 am happy to answer short queries over
the phone, but please, I am a working writer/engineer hence cannot
provide unlimited free services. My apologies to the innumerable
readers who've left messages (in one case, abusive) asking me
to call interstate at my expense. You're welcome to my help.
But you pay for the call!My comments that few auto electricians
understand motorhome electrics applies primarily to the battery
charging system. On that I stand totally unrepentant. The remainder
of a motorhome's electrics are generally similar to car and truck
practice and I did not intend to imply a general lack of competence
in these areas.
An inverter can power some 240 volt appliances from your 12 volt
or 24 volt supply: you can run radios, TVs, shavers, lights, small
microwave ovens, and motor driven appliances (such as drills, blenders
etc). But as with 12 volts, not large-scale heating devices such
as grilles, hot plates, ovens etc.
Older inverters, and today's cheaper inverters,
are around 80% efficiency i.e. they waste 20 amps out of every
100 amps drawn from the battery. Hence running a 240 volt device
via such an inverter uses 20% more battery power than its direct
12 volt equivalent (an amazing range of 12 volt equipment is available
from the suppliers listed in this article).
More expensive inverters are 95% - 98% efficient, hence energy
losses are negligible.
Older, and most cheap inverters generate so-called 'square-waves'
output (as opposed to the sine-waves of mains electricity). Square-waves
will not bother motor driven devices such as blenders, razors etc,
lights or microwave ovens, but may cause hum in radios, tape recorders,
and TVs. Such output is particularly disliked by most computers.
Higher-priced inverters produce vaguely mains-like output.
Most up-market inverters can be left switched on more or less permanently:
they draw only a tiny amount of quiescent power, sensing when an
appliance is switched on.
Appliance and inverter makers think in watts. To determine
the size inverter you need, check the wattage rating of each
appliance. If bought in Australia there will be a label or stamp
denoting volts and watts, e.g. 1 00 watts - or I 00 W. You may
encounter an appliance that just gives volts and amps - if so
multiply amps by 240 to obtain watts.
Total the wattage rating of all the appliances you are likely
to have on simultaneously. That's the wattage rating of the inverter
that you'll need. Good inverters will withstand short-term overloads
so you don't need to panic if you've forgotten to allow for the
coffee grinder whilst watching TV!. Overload ratings will be
specified in the makers' literature.
The current drawn by an inverter from a 12 volt battery is approximately
the wattage drawn by each appliance (when it's in use) divided
by I 0- I 1 for an inefficient inverter, and divided by 12 for
a more efficient unit. Thus a I 00 watt blender will draw somewhere
between about 8 and 1 0 amps; an 800 watt microwave - between
65 and 80 amps.
Warning: Some low-priced imported inverters (particularly
those sold via at least one electronics chain-store) float
the neutral supply at a voltage half-way between active and
earth. Because of this they are incompatible with (and will
not trigger) earth leakage protection switches. This is an
inherently dangerous situation. (In this respect, Australian-made,
and most US-made inverters are fine.) Any qualified electrician
will understand the implications of the above - obtain their
advice if in doubt - but do not rely on an assurance from
the sales person unless he or she is qualified to give it.
Whether mains, or inverter-derived, any 240 volt
system is dangerous if inexpertly installed. Mains-power
wiring must be legally installed by a certified electrician
and the installation then certified by your local electricity
authority.
At the time of writing, this was not a legal requirement
for inverter systems. However, regardless of the legalities,
a camper van or motorhome is an exceptionally dangerous environment
for 240 volts electricity. Unless you really know what you
are doing, have the work done professionally by an electrician
experienced in this type of work.
The above qualification re 'experience' is necessary. Electricians
normally wire buildings using heavy gauge single-strand copper
cable. This is fine for fixed installations, but not where
there may be vibration or movement. Check they use multi-core
cable for mobile homes and camper vans.
Existing mains wiring and power outlets can double for distributing
power from the inverter - but you absolutely must have a
full isolating switch that separates the two systems electrically.
Energy is lost, in the form of heat, when electricity
flows through a cable. These losses are far higher, and more
serious, at low voltages than high (this is why overhead
transmission cables operate at humungously high voltage).
So, as oils ain't necessarily oils, a 15 amp 240 volt cable
is not necessarily a 15 amp 12 volt cable. Run 15 amps at
12 volts through any length of the former cable, and very
few volts will appear at the far end!
This is a trap when wiring a motorhome. Cable intended for
low voltage operation has a hugely larger conductor area
than that intended for 240 volts. It may look much the same
size, but that's because 240 volt cable has thick insulation.
Buy your 12/24 volt cable from a boat supplier, or an auto-electrical
supplier - not a hardware store (the latter's cable will
almost certainly be rated for 240 volts). If you can afford
it, buy the 'tinned' variety - it's less prone to long-term
corrosion.
For lighting, fans, radios, cassette recorders, TVs, coffee
grinders and small non-heating devices, low-voltage 15 amp
cable is fine. For microwaves etc, cable rated at 75 - I
00 amps is not over-kill.
In theory, your switches should really be designed for direct
current operation (switching does produces a momentary electrical
arc). Such switches are available - but do not necessarily
blend well into motorhome decor.
Whilst domestic 240 volt switches are intended for alternating
current operation, in practice they work just fine if used
to switch about 25%- 30% of their originally designed load
- but if one does eventually fail - don't complain to the
manufacturer.
You cannot switch heavy current 12 volt devices, like microwaves,
via a direct switch, unless you use one about the same size
as the device being switched!. Use suitably rated solenoids
instead.
Question:I've shown your article to several
auto-electricians - they all say they've never heard of 'smart
regulators'. Where do I go from here?Answer: This
is of course, a fundamental problem with motorhome electrics:
that the very people who should know about optimising charging
- don't! (In the course of researching this series I did
not come across a single auto-electrician who knew about
it either. Without exception, all advised larger capacity
batteries, and higher output alternators.)Smart regulators
are obtainable from the suppliers listed in this article.
Before ringing, check the make and (if possible) the type
number of your alternator. The supplier may be able to recommend
an installer - but it's not hard to do.
Question:Do solar panels still work on
cloudy days?Answer: The highest output I've
ever seen from my own rig, was around noon on a slightly
hazy day - presumably sunlight was also being reflected off
the earth's surface and re-radiated by the underside of the
haze layer. As a generalisation, expect 40%-50% of the normally
available maximum.
Question: I pull a heavy
trailer fitted with electric brakes, that now and again actuate
momentarily without warning. I've had the entire system checked
many times - and nobody can find anything wrong. Answer: The
cause is almost certainly radio frequency interference (RFI)
from an HF or CB radio, or possibly but less likely, a mobile
phone (most probably your own!). Spurious radiation is being
picked up by your electric brake controller (in the towing
vehicle) and causing it momentarily to actuate.Buy a capacitor
used to reduce electrical interference from alternators (readily
obtainable from most auto electrical supplier for a dollar
or two) and wire it across the 12 volt signal line that actuates
the brakes.
Question: I've recently
bought a big three-way fridge (170 litres) and would still
like to run it off solar panels instead of gas. Your earlier
article says this is not practical and I've spoken to a couple
of panel suppliers who say the same), but
I'm a stubborn old ,so and so' and would still like to do
it! So what size panels do I need to run this fridge alone?
I tend to stay in unpowered sites for a week or two at a
time. Answer: I admire your spirit but stubbornness
cannot change the laws of physics!
Three-way fridges are excellent devices, but are intended
to be powered by 12 volts only when the engine is running,
and by gas, or 240 volts at all other times.
Your's draws a continuous average of 10 amps on 12 volts.
This is around 240 amp/hours per day. You'll generate about
25 amp/hours per day from a (nominal) 77 watt panel, hence
you'll need at least 10 panels (costing you over $6,000 and
requiring over five square metres of roof space. It's possible,
but hardly practical.
Question: I bought some
jumper leads from the hardware store but though they are
marked '400 amps' they won't turn over my engine (3 litre
diesel) even using a new fully charged battery. The store
exchanged them for another pair - but they don't work either.
Answer:
This is a common experience. The '400 amp' rating is meaningless
- except they'll probably carry 400 amps for a few seconds
without melting!
What's happening is that the cross sectional area of the
conductors is far too small for the current, and as a result
most of the battery's energy is being lost heating up the
cable. Essentially there's not enough left to start your
vehicle.
I don't know of proprietary source of high current jumper
leads, but you can make your own (or an auto-electrician
can make them for you). Use the heavy '2BS' rated cable,
and heavy copper alligator clamps (available from Electric
Boat Parts in Roseville, NSW.). They will be heavy and will
cost you a heap - but they'll work.
Question: Can I wire a solar panels and
a regulator in parallel with my alternator charging system,
and/or a battery charger - or must I isolate each from the
other by switches?Answer: No problem with
the solar panels and regulator. It's almost certain to be
OK too with the charger but I'd check that with the solar
panel supplier first.
Question: Any advice on battery chargers?Answer: Yes.
But they need an article on their own! Briefly, there's two
main categories: cheapish and only semi-effective; or extremely
expensive and very effective. There's little in between.If
your need is for topping up batteries from time to time,
and there's a day or two in which to do so, go for the typical
$70 - $150 hardware store item. They realistically produce
about half their nominal rating, and take for ever to charge
a battery beyond 85%, but the alternative is costly.
Really good chargers cost $500 and seriously upwards. They
have similar characteristics to a smart alternator regulator,
but apart from solar panels and leaving the vehicle in the
sun, are the only way to go if your vehicle is used irregularly.
These chargers can be left on continually when the vehicle
is not in use, and as nothing wrecks batteries as thoroughly
as being left discharged, these chargers are well worth their
initial cost.
Suppliers are listed elsewhere in this feature.
Question: My laptop computer
runs from 18 volts. Is there any way to connect batteries
to produce this voltage, or can I obtain an adaptor to convert
12 volts to 18 volts. Answer: Theoretically
yes, but both methods are complex and 'micky mouse'. Simply
buy an inverter (150 watts is adequate) and use the existing
charger. You'll also be able to run small appliances like
coffee grinders off the same supply. Question: I take your
point about having solar panels permanently on the roof,
but I like my vehicle out of the sun. What problems are involved
if I use the panels on a lead, away from the vehicle?Answer:
The major problem is potential theft - solar panels are very
costly. Apart from that there's no problem. Use at least
12 volt 15 amp cable, and 30 amp if longer than more than
ten or so metres. Quirk's Victory Light in Rose Bay (NSW)
sells very neat folding units using two panels. Tell them
you read about it here.
Question: Following your
advice I've fitted a smart regulator, but when I run the
engine with the 'house batteries' isolated , the starter
battery charges so heavily that the electrolyte boils off.
A local electrician says this will wreck the battery and
I should not use this regulator. I've fitted the supplied
battery sensing cable to the house battery but it does not
seem to work. Answer: The
sensing cable is working only too well! What's happening
is this.
The sensing cable uses voltage and temperature information,
from the battery to which it's connected, to control the
rate of charge. When you isolate the house battery, the sensing
cable instructs the regulator to charge the starter battery
using information from the house battery (which because you've
isolated it) is not being charged.
The sensor has no possible way of knowing you've disconnected
the house battery. It's observing that battery's voltage
is exceptionally low (for a battery that it not unreasonably
thinks is being charged) and it's telling the regulator to
develop maximum charge - all of which it's pouring into your
starter battery. No wonder it boils!
There's two solutions. Either is fine. Don't isolate the
house batteries whilst the engine is running (why would you
want to do this anyway?).
Or, if you really must disconnect your house battery, move
the sensor lead permanently to the starter battery
Question: A friend says that it costs nothing
to use solar energy, whilst drawing a lot of power from the
vehicle alternator consumes fuel. Surely his latter point
is not true - the engine's running anyway!Answer: The
cost of using solar power is that spent initially on the
solar panels, regulator etc. From thereon it's free - until
you have to renew the equipment after 10 - 15 years
(a supreme irony concerning solar panels is that they degrade
in sunlight!).
An alternator charging at, say, 100 amps requires about one
and a half horse-power to drive it. The engine must thus
develop one and a half horse power more than if it were not
driving the alternator. To do that requires more fuel be
burnt. Depending on the efficiency of the engine etc, this
amount (for 100 amps) will be about a litre every three or
four hours.
Question: I'm converting a coach to a motorhome
and am about to install all of the wiring. I'm unclear whether
to use fuses or circuit breakers?Answer: They
have different functions and you need both. Circuit breakers
are connected to the 'battery end' of common power cabling
and protect the cable itself against overload, i.e. they
trip in the event of a short circuit that otherwise causes
that cable to be overloaded and possibly bum out (possibly
taking your coach with it!). Circuit breakers should thus
be rated to trip around 10%-20% more than the rated maximum
current rating of that cable. Don't skimp on price - good
circuit breakers cost money.
Fuses protect appliances against continuing to draw current
in the event of a short circuit within an appliance. Fuses
should be rated to blow at a current about 50% more than
the normal maximum for that appliance, and located as close
to the appliance as possible. Most appliances liable to catastrophic
failure have fuses inbuilt. Some manufacturers, e.g. pump
makers, usually supply a separate fuse that you install as
close to the pump as possible.
Question: My present starter
battery does not seem adequate for my 5 litre diesel-powered
coach. What size do I need - presumably in ampere/ hours.
Answer: First
check all connections are clean and tight, particularly the
earthing cable; and that main battery leads have not been
replaced by smaller size cable, or extended in length, perhaps
by a previous owner.If necessary replace the cables using
high quality battery connectors. Use at least 2BS cable.
It is possible however that the battery is not up to the
job.
Ampere/hour capacity is not a useful measure for starter
batteries. Look for the so-called CCA (Cold Cranking Amps)
rating - all battery suppliers will understand this term.
Around 175-200 CCA per litre of engine capacity for a diesel,
and 125/150 CCA per litre for a petrol engine will give you
an adequate safety margin. Err off the high end of the range
for cold climates.
(There are three different definitions of CCA: USA, UK and
European, but the differences are not big enough to worry
about).
Question: In my recently purchased campervan,
all the electrical outlets are cigarette lighter sockets.
The one used for fridge does not seem to make firm contact
- even though I've had both plug and socket replaced. Are
there versions available?Answer: I have
a considerable prejudice against these things. I had some
in my Kombi camper, and finally tore them all out when two
(literally) went up in flames in the outback within a few
days of each other.
The problem with them is that they rely on quite light spring
pressure to maintain contact. If, or more probably when,
this contact pressure is lost, the resistance thus introduced
causes heat to build up, and, if they are used for high currents,
they may eventually ignite.
I have seen better versions of the plugs (in fact Engels
fit a particularly well-made version on their smaller fridges).
But I've yet to see a half-decent socket!I doubt if you want
to hear this, but if the vehicle were mine I'd replace every
single one of them with a different type of connector (my
favourites are made by Bulgin (from Electric Boat .Parts).
They are a bit fiddly to install, but once in place they
are excellent. Use the three-pin version, and ignore one
of the two pins. They carry up to IO amps.
KNOWN SUPPLIERS
Quirk's Victory
Light P/L
1/590 Old South Head Road,
Rose Bay 2029.
(02) 9371 6600.Small company specialising in 12 volt equipment,
including solar panels, regulators, inverters, lights etc.
They even have 12 volt hair dryers, curling tongs, blenders
and provide excellent mail service. Don't be patronising
or sexist when you call! Quirk's is run almost exclusively
by women, and they know a great deal about 12 volt electrics.
Electric Boat Parts
11 Babbage Road
Roseville 2069
02 9417 8423
Another small company with a vast range
of extremely high quality 12/24 volt marine electrical bits
and pieces. This is the company I talk to about smart regulators,
hi-tech battery chargers, up-market plugs
and sockets, lights etc. Ask for David Watkins and mention
you read about his company here. David is an authority on
smart regulators etc.
Whitworth's Marine & Leisure
Various locations in Sydney,
Melbourne, Brisbane.Huge range of mainly boat equipment,
including 12/24 volt electrics. Their range is vast in terms
of quality and price, however whilst generally very helpful,
their staff cannot be expected to have the depth of product
knowledge of specialist suppliers - so they are a good source
of bits and pieces if you know what you are looking for.
Have them post you their catalogue.
Australia-Wide Solar
106 Moreshead Drive
Hurstville Grove 2221
(02) 9580 3760Specialises in solar panels, regulators and
systems, inverters etc. I've no direct experience with this
company, but have heard good reports from Club members.
Twelve Volt Shop
968b Albany Highway
East Vic. Park
WA 6101
(08) 9470 5949
Comments as above.
BEP Marine
83 Proprietary St
Tingalpa
Brisbane 4173
(07) 3890 1115
Australian branch of the New Zealand company
that makes the BEP Marine Electronic Regulator. Less sophisticated
than the Heller regulator used by the author but simpler
to install. Electronic Boat Parts (see above) sell both and
are better placed to advise you re the respective pros and
cons.
Caravan suppliers.
Most have a good range of the medium-quality electrical
bits and pieces used in commercial caravans and camper
vans. If you know what you are looking for they carry some
higher quality bits as well.
But with electrical bits, its false economy to buy anything
but the best - and this quality is normally carried mainly
by boat equipment suppliers. Nevertheless you still need
to be selective: some of the 'chain-store boat suppliers'
also market a great swag of made-to-a-price' equipment.
Collyn Rivers, was originally a research engineer
with General Motors, during which time he spent almost three
years travelling the length and breadth of Africa in a 10 tonne
Bedford 4-wheel drive motorhome/laboratory. He subsequently founded
the international publication Electronics Today International
(ETI), was technology editor of The Bulletin and Australian Business.
Collyn currently produces a telecommunications quarterly for Telstra,
and is working towards completing a practical book on all aspects
of caravan/motorhome and 4WD vehicle technology.
His current vehicles are a 1974 Kombi rebuilt for off-road use, and a Western
Australian built OKA currently being converted into a fully off-road motorhome. |
|
|